The Federal Court decision to rule the former ALP Queensland government’s Wild Rivers legislation invalid is a victory for the future of Indigenous Australians, rescuing many of those in northern and western Queensland from the racist assumptions, and corrupt wheeling and dealing, of Queensland’s major left wing parties.
According to The Australian:
Federal Court judge Andrew Greenwood found yesterday that the decision was made too quickly and without enough consideration of the views of the traditional owners.
“The decision to make the declarations was a function of urgently delivering on an election promise … the declarations got ahead of the formulation of the material addressing the preconditions upon which the exercise of the power rested,” he wrote in his judgment.
The government had received 3062 submissions about the declarations, but 2577 of these were pro forma submissions made through the Wilderness Society’s website.
In other words, the decision was made by the minister without proper consideration, and it was made to secure the preferences of Greens voters.
Ironically the plaintiff in this case, Martha Koowarta, is the widow of John Koowartha, who took the Bjelke-Petersen government to court over land rights. Viewed over the course of 40 years, neither Liberal National, nor Labor have much to be proud of when it comes to land rights.
The decision will allow Aborigines to live in an economy, not just a society, and that is what they so desperately need in isolated areas.
Historically the Australian landscape has been one large farm – the ‘biggest estate on earth” as Bill Gammadge terms it in his book of the same name where he explores Aboriginal land management practices using the evidence available from original eye-witness accounts and still apparent in the landscape.
Modern Greens, through a misguided, romantic view of what nature is, and what is natural, deny the Aboriginal history, and deny Aborigines the opportunity to make a living from their own lands.
What’s more, for their own aesthetics, they would prefer to see Aborigines living what they call a “traditional” lifestyle, making them a scenic ornament, and robbing them of the opportunity to do what most other civilisations on earth have done and adapt and progress.
The sanctified Nelson Mandela may have been born in an African settlement, but he didn’t aspire to keep himself or his people there. The dream of black Africans is to join the Enlightenment project, because that project has delivered human health and well-being, as well as human dignity.
Australia’s indigenous are entitled to join the same project, and the evidence is, that when they do, by moving to the cities and becoming part of the national and international economy, their quality of life improves on a whole range of indices.
Of course, in the modern world the biggest estate on earth has to adapt as well, and who better to manage that than its indigenous owners.
The Bligh government’s authoritarian attitude to Indigenous Australians was not what is needed.
Thankfully the current LNP government appears to have learned from its mistakes in the past and is moving to ensure that not only do native landowners own their own land, but they can have proper title to it.
Changes instituted by the housing minister, with support from the Aboriginal affairs minister, means that Aborigines living in settlements are able to gain individual title to land so that they can raise finance to build their own house, or even create their own businesses.
One of the stupidest phrases that I sometimes hear is that “we live in a society, not an economy”. The plight of Aboriginal Australians, enumerated regularly in state of the nation reports, proves that the sort of society you have without an economy, is one that is unsustainable and damaging to its members.
The judgement is a huge leap forward, but it shouldn’t have had to get to the courts at all. No government should have passed the legislation in the first place.